Cesar's Way: The Natural, Everyday Guide to Understanding and Correcting Common Dog Problems by Cesar Millan
2006
Weight: 12 oz
Method of Disposal: Recycling
I am tempted to burn this thing just to ensure that no one tries to get it out of my recycling bin but, with all the natural disaster surrounding us, I am not sure I should risk adding to the problem--either by not recycling or by burning down my neighborhood! As a shelter manager, I cannot begin to describe the harm done by Cesar. So many adopters assure us that they will be great homes for our pups because they use all of Cesar's methods and they are THE Alphas in their homes. They do not know that every last one of us is cringing. We try to gently, without embarrassing them, lead them in another direction and encourage them to see a professional dog trainer that is more modern, more positive. We know that being uneducated does not mean that they will be bad dog owners in the long run, but we also know that if we let them walk out the door and use Cesar tactics on their new dogs that many of them will come back with a set of issues that is different and more challenging that the ones they might have left with.
It is not common that a dog is euthanized for aggression at our shelter. We see a trainer that specializes in working with aggressive dogs, and we try to screen and prep our adopters with all the information and everything we know. We do have to say goodbye to them sometimes and one of the consistent things I have seen is that these dogs have often been through some fairly intense Cesar-style training and that it has broken the dog's spirit. When they see people they see someone alien who does not have the faintest idea how to communicate with them. There is something broken in these dogs that ,when you start to become aware of it, will make you break down into tears because you will feel the guilt, the disappointment, and the shame of a shelter worker who knows there was a different way. It must be incredibly frustrating for these dogs to live each day with their families, trying to express themselves in so many creative ways and the only thing that makes people listen is what will ultimately get them surrendered and/or euthanized, and that is biting. It is a last resort for many when they first begin trying to communicate but, by the time it becomes their go-to, you have a real problem.
I know there are people out there who use Cesar's methods or methods like them and have great success in molding the dog that they have always envisioned having. Many dogs are so amazing that they learn and love us in spite of us. That is often described as the magic of dogs. Unfortunately, it is the intelligent, the fearful, and the aggressive dogs that usually do the worst with this type of training, and it is those dogs that people are most commonly willing to seek outside help from trainers for. There are a lot of trainers out there that use old school methods of punishment and dominance, and there are many people who are not even certified but, after having read books like these and working with their own dogs, feel like they are experts and can help you. These people seem to be drawn to working with aggressive cases. I do not know why they are drawn to it--maybe it is the challenge--but I can understand why the dog owners are so desperate for a fix that they will try anything, even if it does not sit right with them. It breaks my heart to see a loving owner who never thought they would give up on their dog, who has funneled so much time, energy, and money into mis-training their dog, come into the shelter in defeat. All of those resources could have been used in other, more successful ventures but, by then, the owner is burnt out and cannot hear it. Sometimes, in rare cases, the dog has given up too.
Cesar is right that dogs need exercise and that being calm and collected is essential to communicating with your dog. That is what you might read that is useful in this book. The things that might cause harm are assuming that your dog is like a wolf, that you and your dog are having a power struggle to be the more dominant one, that flooding is a useful tool in overcoming a dog's fears, and Cesar might even encourage you to read the wrong things in your dog's body language. For some dogs, they will continue to be the loving, wonderful pups they were born to be with a little extra fear of their owners but, for other dogs, these methods can make them react and become dangerous. There is a reason his show comes with the warning not to try his methods at home. I would recommend you don't. And, when given a copy of his books or one of his cds, do not pass it along. If you read it, please also talk to other dog trainers and read other books to see if something feels a little more right for you and your pets. I think that many people know in their gut something is wrong with his method, but they want so badly to see a change in their pet that they push that down and dominantly proceed ahead without listening to their own dog. A relationship is built on mutual trust and respect, and it cannot be maintained without good communication. Your relationship with your dog is not different.
